Wally’s Old Fashioned Pizza
About
Pizza, Sandwiches
Price Range : Under $10 ($)
Location
Adress: 805 Miller St, Caldwell, OH 43724
Phone: (740) 732-4241
Work Hours
Business info
- move_to_inboxTake-outYes
- credit_cardAccepts Credit CardsYes
- local_parkingParkingPrivate Lot
- directions_bikeBike ParkingYes
- accessibilityGood for KidsYes
- groupGood for GroupsNo
- transit_enterexitOutdoor SeatingYes
- tvHas TVYes
Reviews
-
Ryan V.
We found this place during a cross country road trip. Staying in Caldwell, we didn't have a lot of options and chose to drive through town to find this spot.
The ladies working there were very friendly and incredibly busy. We ate at a table outside and watched many customers come and go. The pizza was fantastic. It was square cut and loaded with toppings. Despite all of the coverage, the crust was incredibly crispy all the way through.
I have to say, this is one of the best pizzas that I have had in a long time. It's not flashy or trendy, just a straight forward and traditional. I especially liked how they cooked the pepperoni separately and added that with extra cheese after it was baked. This kept it from being as greasy as a lot of others.
I highly recommend stopping here if you're nearby. -
Ottis T.
As a trucker, I was passing through Caldwell and decided to walk from the truck stop (about a mile through gorgeous little town) to try out this pizza place. SO glad I did!
Pizza was perfect crunch, zesty sauce, fresh ingredients, and perfect melty cheese. Service was also perfect, you can tell they truly care about their craft/customers.
Truckers: its worth the walk! -
Bruce C.
Arrived late in town. Stopped because of the 5-star review. Ordered the Italian sub, and certainly a 5-star meal. If you happen through Caldwell, Ohio give it a try. You won't regret it.
-
Abe F.
Traveling from Hilton Head to Cleveland. Screaming kid demanding pizza. The ONLY pizza place near where we were on I-77 was Wally's. As a pizza snob I was highly skeptical of a pizza place in a small town. I was even more skeptical when I pulled up to the place and had to walk through a muddy parking lot to get our pizza to go.
But, darn it, that was some pretty good pizza. It isn't gourmet, it isn't fancy, it isn't Grimaldi's in Brooklyn, it isn't Pequod's in Chicago. Don't come expecting either.
It just tastes good, really good.
So much so that on our next trip to Hilton Head we will actually PLAN to stop in rural Ohio for Wally's. -
Susan C.
Ginormous pieces were very filling. Crust is thick and chewy and toppings were generous. Not what you'd expect from a small town pizzeria (which can sometimes be cardboard). Husband is working in area, so I came down to visit and we've had several time. Will order again.